|
|
August 2006
Super claw back from bankrupts?
|
 Lawyer in Profile  Rebecca SargeantSenior Associate Phone: 03 9288 0555 Rebecca's areas of practice include:
She advises extensively on all areas of taxation and has experience in providing advice to a broad range of clients and business structures. She also has experience in drafting various types of commercial agreements and trust deeds. Rebecca is currently studying for her Masters of Taxation Law at Melbourne University. Rebecca has been assisting in managing the Cleardocs Help Desk as the need arises over the past year.  
Proposed changes to bankruptcy law may allow creditors to claw back superannuation contributions paid by a bankrupt fund member.
Paul Ellis and Amalia Moylan.
The proposed changesThe Federal Government intends to amend the Bankruptcy Act 1966 Act so that a creditor can claw-back superannuation contributions made by a person for the purpose of defeating creditors' claims if that person later becomes bankrupt. The change is the government's response to the Cook v Benson High Court case. The changes are yet to be finalised. But they will take effect from the date the proposed changes were announced - 27 July 2007. The law as it stands: Superannuation contributions and bankruptcyCurrently, transfers of property by a person who later becomes bankrupt can be set aside if:
The aim of these sections is to prevent people who later become bankrupt from defeating creditors' claims by placing their assets, including cash, in the hands of third parties and out of creditors' reach. A case triggers the planned change Cook v BensonThe High Court's decision in Cook v Benson triggered the planned change by casting doubt on whether a transfer in the form of superannuation contributions could be set aside. The doubt arose because of the difficulty in determining the bankrupt's intention. The relevant sections of the Act provide little guidance. There is no specific reference in either section to superannuation contributions. Under the changes:
In Cook v Benson2 contributions were made to a number of superannuation funds in September 1990. The contributions were applied by the funds to make life policy and other investments on the member's behalf — entitling the member to retirement and death benefits. An order for bankruptcy was made against the member's estate in July 1992. The trustee in bankruptcy argued that the contributions were made with a lack of good faith and without consideration: therefore they could be clawed-back under sections 120 and 121.1 The decision:The High Court found that the contributions were made in return for rights and benefits under the funds' policies. These benefits constituted substantial and valuable consideration, and, as a result could not be 'clawed-back'. Would the new law have changed the result in Cook v Benson?If the proposed changes been in force at the time, it is likely the High Court's decision would have been reversed in favour of the creditors. Although the superannuation contributions were made for substantial and valuable consideration, they were made primarily to defeat the prospective claims of creditors. So they could thus be 'clawed-back'. A key factor would have been whether the contributions were out of character given the history of the member's superannuation contributions. SummaryIn future, it seems likely that persons who are insolvent will not be able to put their assets beyond the reach of creditors by making ?Äòout of the ordinary' superannuation contributions. However, the primary consideration will remain whether the insolvent person's objective was to defeat the claims of their potential creditors. 1 Sections 120 and 121 of the Act
To set up on Cleardocs, all you need to do is key in your name, industry, email and password. Then you're ready to create Cleardocs documents. It only takes a few minutes. (There's no joining fee. Just a pay per use document fee.) Existing users wanting to start a new document, log in (top right) |
The legal information and commentary on this site is general only. Documents ordered
through Cleardocs affect the user‘s legal rights and liabilities. To assess their
suitability for the user, legal, accounting and financial advice must be obtained.
